Peak TV has caused casualties. The recent explosion in scripted drama means that not only viewers are struggling to keep up with it all, but even the critics who tell us what’s worth watching. During Battlestar Galactica’s run only a decade ago when fewer mainstream dramas were vying for praise, even a space show could attract critical attention. Now with streaming services and yet more cable channels producing scripted TV, Syfy’s terrific return to space, The Expanse, has struggled to get much buzz. But it deserves to.
While some unwieldy subplots prevent it from operating at Battlestar’s level for now, The Expanse largely succeeds as a drama as well as a space opera adventure. Like its forerunner, it tackles contemporary themes through the prism of SF, including resource depletion, inequality, and geopolitical manipulation.
Based on the novel series by James S.A. Corey, the show is set in a future when the solar system has been colonised but interstellar travel is still unattainable. Tensions are brewing between a decadent but depleted Earth, a militaristic Mars, and the marginalised citizens of the asteroid belt. In the belt, washed-up detective Miller (Thomas Jane) is assigned to look for the missing daughter of an Earth tycoon. Near Saturn, a mining ship called the Canterbury answers a distress signal that leads to catastrophe, turning the survivors into fugitives. And on Earth, United Nations powerbroker Avasarala (Shohreh Aghdashloo) tackles the alleged threat of the Outer Planets Alliance, who want freedom for the belt.
Syfy has given the show a higher budget than any of its previous dramas, allowing for huge, detailed sets and bigger name actors like Jane and Aghdashloo. The production values, dialogue, and acting are strong and the themes are timely. This is a step up from Syfy’s recent efforts, and their first genuinely competitive drama since Battlestar.